KEEP THE PHILLY PI 100% READER-POWERED

Support Independent Journalism in Philadelphia

HELP THE PHILLY PI DELIVER UNBIASED, COMMUNITY-FOCUSED NEWS

The Philly PI relies on reader support to deliver crucial investigative reporting, breaking news, community safety updates, and transparent tech coverage. Independent journalism requires time, deep research, and absolute editorial freedom—free from paywalls, political influence, or corporate control. We cannot keep our newsroom running without you.

  • 100% READER-FUNDED NEWSROOM

  • NO PAYWALLS OR CORPORATE CONTROL

  • KEEP INDEPENDENT JOURNALISM FREE FOR ALL

LATEST IN SCIENCE & TECH

Insects Have Six Legs. But This 324-Million-Year-Old Insect Had 24 Legs and a Body Unlike Anything Alive Today

Insects Have Six Legs. But This 324-Million-Year-Old Insect Had 24 Legs and a Body Unlike Anything Alive Today

For nearly 40 years, one of the strangest insects ever found was…

Panda bears hugging with playful expressions on a red background.

Why Can’t Pandas Get It On? The Answer to Their Poor Sex Lives May Lie in Their Intestines

Poor pandas. While the iconic bear species of China is no longer…

Shooting Lasers to Read Minds: How LIBS Unlocks the Elemental Secrets of Matter | Philly PI

Shooting Lasers to Read Minds: How LIBS Unlocks the Elemental Secrets of Matter

Imagine firing an invisible beam of light at a mystery rock sitting…

Scientists found 149 new deep-sea species — and a 22-million-year shark-tooth graveyard

Scientists found 149 new deep-sea species — and a 22-million-year shark-tooth graveyard

Closeup detail of an Ophiuroid brittle star collected at Muirfield Seamount, southwest…

Singapore Is Culling Thousands of Crows While Building the Perfect Habitat for Them

Singapore Is Culling Thousands of Crows While Building the Perfect Habitat for Them

A crow poisoned by a pest control company at Sungei Tengah Lodge…

Scientists Create ‘Self-Exercising’ Muscle Grafts That Benefit the Whole Body

Scientists Create ‘Self-Exercising’ Muscle Grafts That Benefit the Whole Body

Could an implant do the job of a workout? In humans, not…

$0
Raised
0
Donations
$200
Goal
0%
$

The Philly PI site favicon and logo featuring bold white "PI" lettering on a dark blue background.
LIVE
Subscribe
DONATE
Subscribe
SIGN IN
  • Philly Pulse
  • Politics
  • 2026 Elections
  • Business
  • Security
  • Science & Tech
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • People
  • Shopping

Archives

  • November 2026
  • October 2026
  • September 2026
  • August 2026
  • July 2026
  • June 2026
  • May 2026
  • April 2026
  • March 2026
  • February 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • December 2024

Categories

  • 2026 Elections
  • Affiliate Resources
  • AI
  • Ammo & Ballistics
  • Business
  • China
  • Comedy
  • Crime
  • Culture
  • Europe
  • Fact Check
  • Firearm Reviews
  • Game Guides
  • Gaming
  • Gaming PCs
  • Gear & Ballistics
  • Hacking
  • Health
  • History
  • IPO Watch
  • Iran
  • Israel
  • Japan
  • Lifestyle
  • Market Recon
  • Mexico
  • Military & Defense
  • Military History
  • Missing Person
  • Movies
  • News
  • Opinion
  • People
  • Politics
  • Range & Shooting Sports
  • Russia
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Science
  • Security
  • Shopping
  • Somalia
  • Sport
  • Startups
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • Ukraine
  • Uncategorized
  • Venezuela
  • Video
  • World
★
Midterm Elections 2026
Balance of Power
54 Majority Won Senate (51 to win) 44
● Democrats Republicans ●
253 Majority Won House (218 to win) 150
Tuesday, Nov 17, 2026
LIVE
Subscribe
Donate
Philly PI
Donate
bitcoin
Bitcoin (BTC) $ 63,652.00 1.86%
ethereum
Ethereum (ETH) $ 1,785.19 1.71%
solana
Solana (SOL) $ 72.07 1.11%
bnb
BNB (BNB) $ 585.70 0.61%
dogecoin
Dogecoin (DOGE) $ 0.05847 1.32%
cardano
Cardano (ADA) $ 0.1514 1.01%
tron
TRON (TRX) $ 0.306335 0.16%
monero
Monero (XMR) $ 504.41 0.69%
litecoin
Litecoin (LTC) $ 44.07 1.53%
kucoin-shares
KuCoin (KCS) $ 6.14 1.02%
binance-bridged-usdc-bnb-smart-chain
Binance Bridged USDC (BNB Smart Chain) (USDC) $ 0.999945 0.02%
jupiter-exchange-solana
Jupiter (JUP) $ 0.250171 0.97%
Philly PI
  • Philly Pulse
  • Politics & World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
Search
  • Philly Pulse
  • Politics & World
  • Business
  • Tech & Science
  • Sports
  • Gaming
  • Shopping
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2026 The Philadelphia Post-Intelligencer.
Alienware Aurora ACT1250 gaming PC deal

Save $1,000 on Alienware RTX 5070 Gaming PC with 32GB DDR5 RAM at Newegg

Newegg Reveals Top Cyber Monday Hardware Deals on Laptops and Motherboards

Newegg Reveals Top Cyber Monday Hardware Deals on Laptops and Motherboards

Dr. Joyce Slams Critics and Unveils Major Pennsylvania Voter Hall of Fame Tribute

Dr. Joyce Slams Critics and Unveils Major Pennsylvania Voter Hall of Fame Tribute

Rep. Scott Perry Exposes Massive Organized Fraud Ring In Minnesota Government

Rep. Scott Perry Exposes Massive Organized Fraud Ring In Minnesota Government

50 Iranian Tanker Logjam Unfolds As US Naval Blockade Starves Tehran Of Oil Revenue

50 Iranian Tanker Logjam Unfolds As US Naval Blockade Starves Tehran Of Oil Revenue

Rep. Meuser on Fox News

Rep. Meuser on Fox News

Wanted: Suspect for Vandalism in the 5th District [VIDEO]

PHPD Seeks Public Help Identifying Vandalism Suspect in 5th District [VIDEO]

Meuser on National Report

Meuser on National Report

Wera Advent Calender 2026 Tool Kit in Case

Wera Advent Calendar is Now Shipping

World - China

U.S. Naval Shipbuilding Crisis: Constellation Frigate Program Sparks Debate Over Fleet Modernization and China Threat

U.S. Naval Shipbuilding Crisis: Constellation Frigate Program Sparks Debate Over Fleet Modernization and China Threat | Philly PI
Source: Illustration accompanying Alistair MacDonald and Gordon Lubold, "The Warship That Shows Why the U.S. Navy Is Falling Behind China," Wall Street Journal, March 20, 2025. The caption to the photograph credits the photograph to Fincantieri/Marinette Marine.

The ongoing effort to modernize the U.S. Navy fleet has once again become a flashpoint for criticism, with the new Constellation-class Frigate (FFG-62) program—designed to be the Navy’s versatile, next-generation small surface combatant—at the heart of a heated online discussion regarding defense procurement failures.

U.S. Naval Shipbuilding Crisis: Constellation Frigate Program Sparks Debate Over Fleet Modernization and China Threat | Philly PI
U.S. Naval Shipbuilding Crisis: Constellation Frigate Program Sparks Debate Over Fleet Modernization and China Threat | Philly PI

The thread, titled “U.S. Shipbuilding Disaster,” centers on the perceived systemic problems plaguing American military acquisition programs, particularly comparing the Constellation program to the troubled histories of the Littoral Combat Ship (LCS) and Zumwalt-class Destroyer programs.

U.S. Naval Shipbuilding Crisis: Constellation Frigate Program Sparks Debate Over Fleet Modernization and China Threat | Philly PI
Source: U.S. Navy rendering shown on slide 2 of in Navy briefing entitled “Guided Missile Frigate (FFG 62) Update, Sea Air Space [Exposition],” Captain Kevin Smith, April 5, 2022.

The Constellation Conundrum

The Constellation class, based on the proven Italian/French FREMM frigate, was intended to deliver a highly survivable, multi-mission ship more capable than the LCS. However, a major source of contention, according to analysts in the discussion, is the difficulty and expense involved in trying to adapt a foreign design to meet stringent U.S. Navy standards, particularly for combat survivability and damage control.

One viewpoint suggests that the Navy’s decision to mandate that the frigate meet the same damage control standards as larger destroyers turned the design adaptation into a “fool’s errand,” resulting in massive cost overruns and delays. Critics argue that the program, initially intended to build a large fleet of ships, has already seen its scope curtailed, raising fears that a small number of “orphaned boats” will be too few to justify the effort and logistical changes needed to integrate them into the fleet.


What do you think? Post a comment.


This perspective views the entire program as a failure to “cut losses” or, alternatively, a failure to initially roll back requirements to something more manageable, resulting in billions spent on development with little to show for it.

Domestic Industry and Foreign Reliance

The debate quickly expanded to the health of the U.S. shipbuilding industrial base. A significant point of friction is the question of whether the U.S. should rely more heavily on foreign partners for designs and construction capacity to rapidly meet fleet needs.

- Advertisement -

EXPLORE MORE

Houthis Attack Multiple Saudi Airports, Wounding Bystanders - Warn Civilian Infrastructure Now In Crosshairs

Houthis Attack Multiple Saudi Airports, Wounding Bystanders – Warn Civilian Infrastructure Now In Crosshairs

Yemen's Ansar Allah movement, or Houthis, have over the past 48 hours…

DeepMind’s AI Solved a 50-Year Math Problem—And It’s Accelerating Future Game Engines | Philly PI

DeepMind’s AI Solved a 50-Year Math Problem—And It’s Accelerating Future Game Engines

Google DeepMind’s AlphaTensor is an AI system designed to discover faster, more…

Rep. Meuser on SBC Franchise Hearing

Rep. Meuser on SBC Franchise Hearing

As lawmakers on Capitol Hill continue to evaluate the challenges facing American…

The box was opened very simply!

The box was opened very simply!

Yes, the answers are a classic riddle killer. Andreas Ruprecht, an expert…

Online Forum Devours Itself Over Ancient Khazar Theory: Phenotypes, Genetics, and Geopolitics Exploded | Philly PI

Online Forum Devours Itself Over Ancient Khazar Theory: Phenotypes, Genetics, and Geopolitics Exploded

INTERNET — A fierce debate erupted on an anonymous online message board,…

Massive Star Wars Secret Revealed: What Every Streamer Needs To Know Right Now

Massive Star Wars Secret Revealed: What Every Streamer Needs To Know Right Now

The digital landscape for content creators is constantly shifting, bringing new challenges,…

One side vehemently rejects the idea, arguing it would create an unsustainable national security risk, making the U.S. “totally existentially dependent” on foreign infrastructure.

The opposing argument suggests that adopting and adapting proven foreign designs is a common-sense method to rebuild a domestic workforce and manufacturing expertise. This approach, they argue, allows the U.S. to “buy foreign ship, make adjustments, build, see what went well and what didn’t,” and ultimately cultivate a more experienced domestic shipbuilding base capable of designing and building its own advanced fleet in the future.

The Shadow of China

Looming over the domestic shipbuilding critique is the rapid naval expansion of the People’s Liberation Army Navy (PLAN). The size and speed of China’s naval buildup acts as the strategic backdrop for the urgency felt in U.S. procurement.

This comparison generated a split among commentators:

  • The Skeptics: Many dismiss the Chinese threat, calling their vast new navy “untested and unproven” with “zero naval tradition.” This viewpoint holds that the PLAN’s capacity is merely “bling” and that its actual combat readiness and institutional knowledge for large-scale naval warfare are far behind the U.S.
  • The Realists: Others caution against underestimation. They point out that in the age of missile warfare, historical “naval tradition” matters less than technological capability. Given China’s demonstrated high-tech research and development capabilities, particularly in missile technology, they argue it is reasonable to consider them a dangerous and modern adversary. They stress that the pace of PLAN construction—with an estimated 75% of their fleet built since 2010—demands a rapid and effective U.S. response, not complacency based on historical advantage.

Ultimately, the discussion highlights a deep-seated frustration with the U.S. defense procurement system, characterized by high costs, shifting requirements, and organizational challenges that critics argue are hindering the nation’s ability to respond effectively to global naval competition.

TAGGED:Chinese Navy (PLAN)Constellation-class FrigateDefense IndustryDefense ProcurementFFG-62Fleet ModernizationGeopoliticsLittoral Combat Ship (LCS)Military AcquisitionNaval StrategyShipbuilding CrisisU.S. NavyUS ShipbuildingZumwalt-class
Share This Article
Facebook Telegram Threads Copy Link Print
By
Tim Errol
December 9, 2025
Share
Picture of Tim Errol

Tim Errol

All Posts

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Subscribe
Connect with
Login
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
Notify of
guest
Connect with
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Top stories

Dr. Joyce Demands Crucial Solutions to Overhaul Modernizing Drinking Water Fund

Dr. Joyce Demands Crucial Solutions to Overhaul Modernizing Drinking Water Fund

As communities across the United States grapple with aging…

Philadelphia Icon Pat Croce Unveils Inspiring Secrets in New Life-Changing Book

Philadelphia Icon Pat Croce Unveils Inspiring Secrets in New Life-Changing Book

PHILADELPHIA — For generations of sports fans across the…

zerohedge logo

Lingering Iranian Diplomats In New York 'Kicked Out' By Rubio

The 81st session of the United Nations General Assembly…

The Neoconservative Echo: Inside the World of Marc Thiessen | Philly PI

The Neoconservative Echo: Inside the World of Marc Thiessen

From Bush-era speechwriter to Fox News fixture, a look…

Stacy Garrity Exposes Josh Shapiro and Demands Major Changes to PA Budget

Stacy Garrity Exposes Josh Shapiro and Demands Major Changes to PA Budget

HARRISBURG, Pa. — As the landscape for the upcoming…

As French Riots Escalate, 'Wild Horde' Beats Police Commander Unconscious, Stomps His Head

As French Riots Escalate, 'Wild Horde' Beats Police Commander Unconscious, Stomps His Head

Authored by Steve Watson via Modernity.news,A French police commander…

Dr. Joyce Exposes William Swartzwelder’s Crucial 70-Year Legacy of Public Service

Dr. Joyce Exposes William Swartzwelder’s Crucial 70-Year Legacy of Public Service

In a powerful demonstration of congressional recognition on Capitol…

Stacy Garrity Vows Major Economic Shift in High-Stakes Pennsylvania Gubernatorial Bid

Stacy Garrity Vows Major Economic Shift in High-Stakes Pennsylvania Gubernatorial Bid

HARRISBURG, Pa. — As the political landscape in the…

Russian Defense Ministry Unveils Advanced T-80 Tank Modification in New State TV Footage

Recent defense broadcasts on Russian federal television network NTV…

Rep. Perry Unveils Major Sunshine Protection Act Update in Crucial House Address

Rep. Perry Unveils Major Sunshine Protection Act Update in Crucial House Address

As lawmakers on Capitol Hill navigate the legislative priorities…

Related Articles

Featured Image
News

Carney downplays China threat before visit, says US a greater security risk

By
Sarah Jenkins
3 Min Read
Featured Image
News

Democrats seek to nullify Electoral College before 2028 election: scholar

By
Sarah Jenkins
7 Min Read
Featured Image
News

Colleges admit students who didn’t apply to boost ‘diversity’: report

By
Sarah Jenkins
4 Min Read
Religious Roots, Legislation, and Public Debate: PA Senator Doug Mastriano’s Post Sparks Viral Online Conversation | Philly PI
PoliticsNews

Religious Roots, Legislation, and Public Debate: PA Senator Doug Mastriano’s Post Sparks Viral Online Conversation

By
Armin Ferdi
4 Min Read
‘Not Just Boomers’: Gen Z Traders Hoodwinked in $8M AI-Generated Memecoin Rug Pull | Philly PI
BusinessNews

‘Not Just Boomers’: Gen Z Traders Hoodwinked in $8M AI-Generated Memecoin Rug Pull

By
Tim Errol
5 Min Read
Featured Image
News

School district ordered to apologize, pay $275k for forcing kids to hide Bibles

By
Sarah Jenkins
4 Min Read

Free Philly PI Newsletter

Brings you a selection of the latest news, trends, insights, and tips from around the world.

You’ve been successfully subscribed to our newsletter!

Philly PI

Sections & Features

  • Philly Pulse
  • Politics & World
  • Business
  • Tech & Science
  • Sports
  • Gaming
  • Shopping


  • Entertainment
  • Tech
  • Health
  • Fact Check
  • Crime Report

In-Focus

  • Iran War
  • Indie Vanguard Awards Hub
  • On air
  • Write for The Philly PI
  • Sign up / Login
  • Donate
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms Of Use
  • Subscription Terms
  • Sitemap
  • Philly Pulse
  • Politics & World
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Entertainment

© 2026 The Philadelphia Post-Intelligencer. All Rights Reserved. The Philadelphia Post-Intelligencer is your trusted source for comprehensive and balanced news coverage. With a commitment to integrity and accuracy, we provide in-depth reporting that uncovers the stories that matter most.

The Philly PI Newsletter
  • Daily Stories
  • Stock Arlets
  • Full Acess
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

You’ve been successfully subscribed to our newsletter!

$0
Raised
0
Donations
$200
Goal
0%
$

The Philly PI Newsletter
  • Daily Stories
  • Stock Arlets
  • Full Acess
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

You’ve been successfully subscribed to our newsletter!

$0
Raised
0
Donations
$200
Goal
0%
$

wpDiscuz
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?

Not a member? Sign Up